The razing of Melos, and the selling of its inhabitants into slavery, was not a ” Strutture e funzione del dialogo in Tucidide e in PseudoSenofonte”, In , La . El diálogo de los melios es un pasaje perteneciente al Libro V () de la Historia de la Guerra del Peloponeso, escrita por el historiador griego Tucídides. Přečtěte si nejlepší citáty od autora Tucídides. Para el político ateniense homónimo, véase Tucídides. Tucídides fue un h.
|Published (Last):||5 December 2006|
|PDF File Size:||7.1 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||16.71 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Halle, of the policy planning staff of the Department of State. Book 1 45 When ttucidides battle took place at Tanagra in Boeotia the Lacedaemonians and their allies doalogo and there were heavy casualties on both sides. The work has transformed itself. It is the independent island states and the disgruntled subjects that Athens has already conquered that are more likely to take up arms against Athens. The Athenians had hundreds of such presumptuous donors.
Were there Spartan readers? Various answers to this question were proposed in the scholarship of the s and s. The effect of this section, then, is to intensify the discrepancy between the analysis of power in the fialogo and the reader’s knowledge of the outcome of the war. The phrase is repeated in 1. It says nothing about the widespread rumor that Pericles had bribed King Pleistoanax of Sparta to withdraw his army from Attica. After an initial section devoted to the tucieides of the Athenian walls and the acquisition of the leadership of the war against the Persians chs.
See Gomme in HCT on 1. Such assertions have some validity when strictly applied to the rhetorical figure of irony see E.
Batalla de Melos
These omissions suggest that the Pentecontaetia is incomplete and would have received further revision if Thucydides had lived. Gardner writes it weighed exactly 9, grains, which is about grams.
Should it not directly have followed the Archaeology? A comparison of the use of imoiltia in 2. It has a neutral, perhaps even technical or scientific tone, as do many of the -sis coinages of the late fifth century, cf. If so ve, we can devise elaborate surveys or in-depth interviews and exploit the techniques of the social sciences to tucjdides “reader response.
This is an unusual way to say “don’t send another embassy. Part of Thucydides’ point is that groups were very small and easily dislocated. The proud Melians refused, and after a siege the Athenians captured their city, slaughtered the men, and enslaved the women and children.
The sources of power detected in the opening portion of the work should have a persistent role in history and help illumine the present as well as the past. Tekmeria are not “proofs” of incontrovertible evidence, but “indications”—facts or observations that point in a certain direction. Taubler, Die Archdoiogie des Thukydides.
Or again, they are bold even beyond their power andrisktakers even when reason says no and full of hopes in the midst of trouble. Although her ambassadors stress the justice of their case, they are on weak ground and their arguments are largely tendentious and ultimately irrelevant.
mslos First, what scholarship had long designated “the Thucydidean question” seemed, if not dead, at least moribund. What of the dislocations that followed the Trojan War or the immense movements and destruction fucidides the second Persian invasion? But it is only well after the Trojan War that the process of “uprooting” abates sufficiently for more general security But since a trading ship bound for Sicily or Italy would not need to cling to the coast, although a warship needed to put into shore each night, the phraseology hints at a military expedition.
Siege of Melos – Wikipedia
Different passages suggested different attitudes toward, for example, the reason for the failure of the Sicilian expedition or toward Alcibiades or Brasidas. Amid the immense scholarly literature on this problem de Ste. These factors, as we have seen, point strongly toward Athenian success.
Since the Peloponnesians wanted to help the Aeginetans [in their struggle with Athens], they landed three hundred Corinthian and Epidaurian hoplites as auxiliaries [on Aegina]. History of the Peloponnesian War5. Plato Laws e; IG i3 84 lines 7 and 12; treatises or technical works: Every reader knows, of course, that Athens lost the war, but Thucydides’ analysis up to this point has provided no help in explaining her ultimate defeat.
This information is absolutely indispensable to the intellection of a work. Some were killed; some captured and later put to death. Against this background the narrative turns to Pericles and to the first of a series of his speeches reported in the first and second books.
In a constitutional sense his powers were very limited, though his influence was great.
Book 1 47 circumstances. But there is also a psychological or ethical side to the growth of power. The Corinthian speech was given before delegates from a large number of cities and the vote was by no means unanimous 1.
Strasburger, “Thukydides und die politische Selbstdarstellung der Meloss Hermes 86is insufficiently critical of the fourthcentury evidence and underestimates, 1 believe, the distinctive tone of Greek political life in the time of the Peloponnesian War. The two phrases coalesce in the discussion of Troy: Thucydides’ work revealed a precedent for our own polarized world, and might, we hoped, provide a guide through the perils of contemporary international affairs.